I never made a Halloween costume for Fluffy. One year I sewed a cape for Scooter so he could be a bat. Another year, in an attempt to save money, I sewed him a Harry Potter cloak that ended up costing more than a store-bought one. I have to admit, though, it was a very nice cloak made of expensive, satiny fabric, and it had a secret pocket to hold his wand. Anyway, that was the last costume I sewed.
However, this year, Fluffy and her friend Kristen announced that they were going as salt and pepper shakers. I definitely wouldn't find those costumes at Party City. So I bought sparkly flannel in black and white, and each mom sewed her daughter's outfit. They wore aluminum foil "caps" on their heads.
Fluffy was salt. She looked really different from the pepper. She had a giant "S" on her front, and people would go, "S...Super...?"